Butterball Turkey Fryer Reviews: The Ultimate Indoor Fryer!

You are currently viewing Butterball Turkey Fryer Reviews: The Ultimate Indoor Fryer!

The days are gone that Thanksgiving dinner is served with a brown turkey dipped in a huge quantity of hot oil. The traditional method of frying using a pan or a pan of oil that is hot to the touch is slowly decreasing because of the recently developed turkey fryers.

Turkey fryers are a great piece of equipment for cooking in your kitchen. If you’re looking to decrease how much oil you use as a result of frying food items, turkey fryers are the best way to take it.

They are a great way to reduce the amount of oil you consume. Butterball turkey fryer sparked our curiosity, and that is the reason why the Butterball review of the turkey fryer is about.

Is the Butterball Turkey Fryer Perfect for  Thanksgiving?


Credit: Eater

1.Masterbuilt MB23010618 Fryer

Masterbuilt MB23010618 Fryer

If you’re planning to cook turkeys that weigh up to 20 pounds, this is the perfect size of fryer you should pick.

A Masterbuilt fryer made by Butterball can cook, fry, and steam your favorite food items using 33 percent less oil than conventional fryers. It only requires 2 gallons of oil if you intend to fry.

This means you don’t have to worry regarding your overall health, specifically your heart. This is fab news for those who are trying to cut down on fats.

You can cook food all day long all year long. The fryer has a fast-heat system that fries your turkey as well as other meals in less time. In just sixty minutes, the fryer will have cooked your turkey as well as other meals. No worries about taking up longer than normal in the kitchen!

This isn’t the case with traditional fryers.

The aluminum basket is equipped with drain clips that are patent-pending and designed to help drain the excess oils. The drain clips have an attachment hole, making it easy to attach the basket. You can raise or lower the turkey and take it out of hot oil.

The fryer comes with an inbuilt timer and automatic shut off features. The built-in timer lets you determine the time you’d like your food to be cooked, and once the time is up to the desired amount, the fryer ceases to cook.

Automatic shutoff switches off the device when it is very hot. This feature will ensure that you’re safe when making use of the fryer.

Two indicator lights inform you about the status of your fryer, the green and red lights. The red light means that the appliance is turned on and the green light indicates that the fryer is heated enough to continue cooking.

The product comes with an open lid that permits steam to escape from the machine should it begin to overheat. Ventilated lids are an aspect that makes the Masterbuilt model a fantastic purchase for large to medium-sized families.

Masterbuilt Butterball fryer is dishwasher safe. The components, which include the lid, drain for oil, and basket, are simple to wash. This is a great fryer that cooks healthy and delicious food items.

Also check: Deep fryer Expert chosen recipes



  • Simple to clean The product is dishwasher safe making it effortless to clean.
  • It has a variety of temperature controls. Whether you wish to boil or steam vegetables, steam water, or fry turkeys, there’s a temperature to suit it. You just need to adjust and control the heat while cooking your food.
  • It cooks quickly – You can prepare your 20-pound turkey in just 60 minutes. Masterbuilt Butterball is an efficient time-saver that many think of as a benefit.
  • It’s easy to use. The great aspect about this fryer is that it’s fairly simple to operate. The instructions are fairly straightforward, and you’ll learn the controls in just a couple of minutes.



2. Masterbuilt Butterball Turkey Fryer

Masterbuilt Butterball Turkey Fryer

The Butterball indoor electric turkey fryer is a favored fryer of many. There’s nothing wrong with deep-fried turkey. There are stories of fries and near-missed opportunities that discourage the biggest turkey lover.

This Butterball Indoor Electric Turkey Fryer is well-designed. It’s also safe for use in homes. This means you can reap the benefits of the turkey inside your home at any time. Its Butterball features are well-designed to provide safety to users.

The porcelain-coated inside the pot is able to conserve oil for a lengthy period of time and reduce oil consumption by 33% over the turkey fryer that is normally used.

Best recipe for this fryer: Burger king chicken nuggets



  • Ability to grill Turkey up to 20 pounds. Inside the aluminum cooking basket together with the drain clip.
  • Digital timer as well as analog controls along with the thermostat control for temperature
  • Simple to clean and comes with an easy oil drain valve
  • Tested and made by the demands of commercial standards
  • Electric heating element 1650 watt quickly heats up. If you want something less powerful, check out Delonghi Roto deep fryer or Waring Pro deep fryer.
  • A magnetic breakaway power cord to ensure security



  • It’s extremely helpful to prepare meals for large families.
  • Keep your oil to heat for a prolonged period of time to cook your food for the amount of time that you require.
  • Excellent for all kinds of food without having them individually.
  • It is able to cook poultry and turkeys with ease and is able to brown well.



  • The heating cabinet with a lid is a must-have in most kitchens.
  • Large enough, so you can take a large area to preserve it or store it.

3.Butterball Xxl Digital 22LBS. Turkey Fryer

Butterball XXL Digital 22 lb. Turkey Fryer

This Butterball XXL Digital 22 lb fryer has electronic temperature control as well as the ability to set a timer. It can take extra time to cook the bird. It is possible to cook food using crisp skin.

There is no requirement for a cooking space in order to cook your dishes. In a short period of time, you can prepare food for your family with numerous members.

It is not necessary to be spending all morning in the kitchen. The XXL fryer is capable of cooking 22 pounds in just a few minutes. You can also use this time to perform other things.

It uses one-third less oil than traditional fryers. This makes food taste better and more cost-effective. Cleaning is simple.

The drain valve drains the oil. The interior of the pot has an enamel coating that makes it easy to clean. It can be used for any other day during the holidays. It can be used as an indoor fryer, so you can use it at any time, any location.

Best recipe for this fryer: Deep fried chicken tenders



  • Variable temperature control option for temperatures up to 375°
  • Made in drain valve
  • Created using a digital timer
  • The outer shell is constructed of stainless steel.
  • Fill with water up to the max.
  • The use of olive oil or any other oils with a low smoke point for cooking.
  • Use the porcelain coating inside the pot to make it easy to clean.



  • Simple to keep
  • It has many safety features.
  • Simple to keep clean
  • Useful for big families



  • It requires more space to house the unit.

4. Masterbuilt Butterball Oil-Free Fryer

Masterbuilt Butterball Oil-Free Fryer

This Masterbuilt Butterball Electric Turkey Roaster has been designed to provide healthier food options. For people who are concerned about their health, the quality features of this fryer have been improved.

The oil-free roaster gives you the perfect moist and tender meat, as well as soft-crisp. It appears and tastes similar to a turkey that has been fried. There will not be any oil in the food.

The roadster produces enough heat to melt the turkey’s food on its outside. The inside of the food remains moist while the exterior of the food is crispy.

Thanks to the Masterbuilt for its ability to cook 18 pounds with just 10 minutes per pound which is close to 3 hours.

Best recipe for this fryer: Wendys chicken nuggets



  • To eat healthily, one can utilize an oil-free electric turkey roaster and fryer.
  • Size 18 inches x 23.2 inches x 26.2 inches (W x H x) A 90-day limited warranty.
  • Double-wall construction provides radiant heat to the exterior of the bird.
  • The 1650 watt power element is used to prepare turkeys that weigh 18 pounds.
  • Wood chip box is an alternative drip pan on the inside of the fryer’s bottom.



  • Ultra quick Turkey cooking
  • Do not tie down the oven or turn on the heat in your home.
  • Excellent to cook with seal in juices.



  • Cleaning the insides of the fryer can be painful since it is a basket-hung structure and heating element inside of the fryer.

5. Masterbuilt 20020107 Propane Turkey Fryer

Masterbuilt 20020107 Propane Turkey Fryer

The propane turkey fryer made by Butterball is another very powerful fryer to have on your kitchen counter. It doesn’t matter if you want to boil, fry or even steam. This machine can do everything.

For those who are only getting started with a turkey fryer, this one is a great option. It can handle all of the essential cooking requirements and will ensure you that you will eat healthier food all through the year.

This Masterbuilt 20020107 Butterball XL turkey fryer is an oven that can hold 30 quarts. They are able to cook 20 pounds—18 lbs of turkey. For a family of moderate size, the fryer will do the job just fine.

Usually, it includes everything that is standard for an electric Masterbuilt turkey. It also has an electronic timer, which operates like the traditional timers on different turkey fryers.

After you have set the time, the fryer will start cooking and stop once the timer is set to expire. If you want to cook on, simply restart the timer, and the fryer will begin cooking.

The auto-shutoff function is available as well to stop any overheating or cooking the fryer too much. This feature helps ensure that fire-related accidents can be avoided.

One feature that is truly unique is the inclusion of a temperature thermometer made of stainless steel. The thermometer is employed to check whether the temperatures in the oil are high enough, which will let you know if the oil is heated too much or not.

The equipment has a temperature control that can read up to 375 degrees Fahrenheit. If you’re looking to boil, steam or fry, there’s an appropriate temperature. Simply turn the knob to alter the temperature to match the cooking.



  • Included is a thermometer for measuring the temperatures of oil. Butterball includes the thermometer, making monitoring simple.
  • Lower use of oil when compared to traditional fryers, which use 5 gallons of oil. The Masterbuilt Butterball electric turkey fryer makes use of just 2.5 gallons of oil. This means you can eat healthier food items.
  • Simple to clean – It’s made from stainless and dishwasher-free, making it simple to clean.
  • Can be controlled by temperature – The electric fryer came with a variety of temperature settings to fit the cooking method. If you’re looking to boil, steam or fry, just adjust the temperature knob, and you’re good to go.
  • Increases safety – The addition of the auto-shutoff function allows fires, as well as other accidents to be avoided. Additionally, there’s a magnetic breakaway cord to provide extra security.



  • It might not be the best choice for the needs of a large family.

Buying Guide of Butterball Turkey Fryer


Before buying the Butterball turkey fryer, you must consider certain aspects. These include:

Sizes/Capacities of the Fryer

Butterball turkey fryers are available in different sizes, including large fryers and XL fryers. Size is important since they determine the amount of food you’ll need to fry.

For instance, the XL turkey fryers will cook as much as 20 pounds of turkey, while the larger turkey fryers can cook up to 14lbs. of turkey.

Additional Functionalities

Butterball fryers are equipped with extra options like the auto-shutoff feature, which switches off the fryer to prevent it from overheating. If the fryer gets excessively hot, the machine instantly switches off. It’s important to wait until it cools down before you begin cooking again.

Cooking Basket

The cooking baskets in Butterball air fryers are constructed from stainless steel and aluminum materials. The baskets are designed to guarantee that lifting and taking off the turkey from the oil is a breeze. They can also be used to remove excess oil prior to placing the turkey on a plate.

Ease of Cleaning

Butterball turkey fryers are made of stainless constructions that are simple to clean. The pot inside the fryers is equipped with drain valves that make it easy to clean. The fryer is dishwasher safe that allows for a clean and safe wash.

How to Use Butterball Turkey Fryer

  • The turkey fryer should be placed on a surface that is heat-resistant.
  • Make sure that the components of the fryer are clean prior to use.
  • Put the ingredients into the basket along with the dish you’d like to cook in accordance with the capacity of your fryer.
  • Connect the power cord to an electrical source.
  • Decide the temperature and the time.
  • When the timer is off, take the fryer out of the oven. If you find that the food remains uncooked, set the temperature and cook time, then continue cooking.

Cleaning and Maintenance of Butterball Turkey Fryer

  1. If the machine stops working because of overheating, allow it to cool before you reuse it.
  2. As the appliance has dishwasher safety, you can clean the fryer and its components.
  3. When you’re done using the fryer, disconnect the device and put it away in a dry, cool area.

How a Butterball Turkey Fryer Works

This question isn’t easy for a reason. The turkey is housed in a basket or holder basket and kept in a heated source. The heat source is fixed.

This means that the turkey will cook faster as opposed to an oven. It takes only twenty minutes to cook a pound of food. Here’s a timeline to prepare a turkey in your turkey fryer.

  • The oil heats up in 3.5 minutes per pound.
  • The oil is heated by propane in 3.5 mins per pound.
  • Air is heated using electricity within 10 mins per pound.
  • The propane-fueled air is heated within 10 mins per pound.

A turkey fryer is much faster than roasting a turkey in an oven traditionally. The four varieties used in turkey fryers have become widespread in the marketplace.

Things Worth Considering Every Day

When lifting, hooks use stainless steel baskets during the process of lowering into the oil that is hot. This will prevent getting burned with hot oil.

Maintain your turkey at the defrost point, and make sure that there is no water on the turkey. In addition, make sure there aren’t any crystals in the turkey. Hot water and oil can be an unwise combination that can easily cause fairness.

To obtain the crisp skin, completely submerge the bird in boiling oil—a bird weighing 14 pounds the capacity fryer that can finish that is outside of the limit. The pieces are nice and crisp.

One customer said that you should lower the basket down into the hot oil to form an oily coating with the fryer. Keep the food items that are raw inside the basket in order to lower the temperature of the oil.

What Dishes Can Be Prepared Using Butterball Turkey?

Advance Cooking Machine

In order to cook a piece of turkey breast, the temperature and cooking time will vary. You must set the temperature to 375 degrees F.

It takes 7 minutes to cook one pound of food. When you cook the meat from the breast in hot oil, you will need to reduce the temperature to 325 degrees F. to cook the meat. Choose the temperature that is lowest.

Which Butterball Turkey Fryer Is Best?

Both varieties make excellent crispy chicken. This is a personal preference. Here are a few comparisons between those who use the Butterball Turkey Fryer that uses oil and an alternative Butterball Turkey Fryer which is oil-free:

  • Gravy can be made from Butterball Turkey Fryer that is oil-free.
  • Here are a few crucial comparisons between the two types of Butterball Turkey Fryers. Selecting the one that’s most suitable for your needs will depend on your needs.
  • Turkeys cook faster using the Butterball Turkey Fryer, which is powered by petroleum.
  • Crispier Skin Care is created by using ingredients in the Butterball Turkey Fryer, which utilizes petroleum.
  • Butterball Turkey Fryer oil-less is significantly more secure.

Butterball Turkey Recipe for Fryers

Deep-Fried Turkey Marinade Recipe



  • 1/4 cup black pepper
  • Two teaspoons garlic powder
  • half cup cayenne pepper
  • One bottle Italian Dressing (16 oz.)
  • one cup Creole seasoning



Mix cayenne pepper along with the 1/4 of Italian dressing Creole seasoning powder, garlic and black pepper into a bowl that is standard. Rinse the mix over the exterior part of your turkey.

Spread the remainder of 14 of the Italian Dressing and cover the turkey’s cavity. Keep it in the refrigerator for night long or 8 hours. Remove it from the refrigerator and fry in accordance with the directions from the Indoor Butterball Turkey Fryer Manual.

Deep-Fried Oreos Recipe



  • One large egg
  • One cup of pancake mix
  • Chocolate sandwich cookies
  • Oil to fry
  • 2 teaspoons of vegetable oil
  • One cup of milk



  • Place the oil inside a deep-fryer, and the heat can be raised to 350 degrees F.
  • Mix together egg, milk, and vegetables in a bowl until it is smooth. Add the pancake mix until there is no lump. Pour the chocolate cookie mixture into the batter in a single layer in order to coat them completely.
  • Keep the cookies in the fryer, paying attention to each one at a time. Fry occasionally to prevent sticking to the pan. Cook for about 2 minutes or until the outside turns golden brown. Utilize the basket or tongs to lift it out of the oil.
  • Place it on the plate and cover with an absorbent paper towel to get rid of oil. You can also cool the cookies prior to eating.

Butterball Turkey Fryer FAQs

Is the Butterball Turkey Fryer Safe?

The Butterball turkey fryer can be described as among the most secure fryers to use. It's fully licensed to use indoors and efficiently cooks.

Is the Butterball Turkey Fryer Good?

Butterball turkey fryers work well as fryers you can trust. It's dishwasher safe and easy to use and is one of the top turkey fryers in the market.

What's wrong with my turkey fryer? Why won't it switch on?

The safety switch on the fryer needs to be installed to turn on the power. When the panel has been properly mounted, the power light should be illuminated.

How much oil is needed?

Fryer requires 2.75 Gallons of oil maximum. The maximum filling level is the highest point that the fluid is at. It's safe to use. The line can be stretched to more than enough oil or water to make sure that food is served to the highest quality.

What type of oil should be used?

Peanut oil is recommended to use because it can provide more smoke and excellent taste. It is also possible to use another cooking oil to accomplish this.

What size does Turkey fit into the Butterball Turkey Fryer?

Butterball turkey fryers are available in two sizes: they are the XL and the larger electric fryer. The XL can take twenty pounds of turkey, while the larger size could accommodate up to 14 pounds of the same bird.

Are Electric Turkey Fryers Good?

Instead of gas-operated fryers, one that is electric can be a great option. The electric turkey fryers can be simple to use, and you don't have to worry about gas leaks or a lack of gas to fill the tanks.

Do you have the ability to steam The Masterbuilt Butterball?

Yes, you can steam and boil and fry using this Butterball turkey fryer.

How much oil will be converted to heat?

The temperature will increase up to 375 degrees F after 45 minutes. If you store your turkey inside the fryer, it will cook lower. Follow the instructions to set the timer.

When I use the product, is it possible to add a lid?

The lid does assist in keeping heat inside and helps to contain splatters within the device.

How much turkey should be thrown into the fryer?

Suggested Turkey is A 14-18lb (6.35-8.16kgs). But, you can cook deep to the 20lb (9.07kgs) turkey inside this device. Don't exceed 20lbs (9.07kgs).

Final Thoughts


The search for the top turkey fryer can be a challenge. But the Butterball review of turkey fryers showed it to be a reliable turkey fryer. Butterball turkey fryers have proven to be durable and are excellent to use.

If you are looking to control your diet and reduce the number of fats you consume, you can start by using a fryer such as one the Butterball Turkey Fryer.

Mathew Smith

Mathew Smith is a chef, food writer, recipe developer, and expert at testing products (especially air fryers). In addition, he is the culinary director at JoyfulFryer.com, who shares honest knowledge and some mad genius tips on various recipes that he on his own have generated. Also, he has participated in many master chef competitions, going up to top 10 ranks. He masters over 13 different nations’ recipes and is among the fastest cooks in our entire team. Currently, he manages a team under him to generate knowledge-packed guides about appliances and recipes at JoulFryer.com.

Leave a Reply